How to Move Information Into Long-Term Memory
- Holding a word in mind and repeating it for longer did not make people recall it later.
- Of words answered yes, those judged for meaning were recognized several times as often as those judged for letter case (96% vs 18%).
- A slow, shallow task that took twice as long left less than a quick task about meaning.
- What moves information into long-term memory is not how long it stays in mind but what you do with it.
- Think about its meaning, tie it to what you know, close the book and recall it, recall it again later, then sleep.
Information moves into long-term memory through what you do with it while it is in mind, not through how long it stays there. In one experiment, students who held a word in mind for longer did not recall it any better later. In another, the same words were recognized several times as often when people had thought about their meaning instead of their letters. Think about what it means, tie it to what you know, close the book and recall it, recall it again after a gap, and sleep.
Does repeating something in your head move it to long-term memory?
Repeating alone did not. Staying longer in short-term memory did not move a word into long-term memory.
In the early 1970s, widely accepted models of memory held that the longer an item stayed in short-term memory, the more of it was transferred to long-term memory. Craik and Watkins (1973) tested that idea directly. 54 students listened to 27 lists of 21 words. Their task was to write down, after each list, only the last word that began with a given letter. So whenever a word with that letter came up, they held it in mind, and dropped it for the next one when another word with the same letter arrived. While they held a word, anywhere from 0 to 12 other words went by. The students were told they were the control group in a perception-memory experiment, and at the end they were asked, without warning, to write down every word they could remember.
Words held in mind longer were not recalled more later
- Word written at the end
- Word replaced midway
See the numbers
| Words that went by while holding it | Word written at the end | Word replaced midway |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 22% | 12% |
| 1 | 19% | 12% |
| 2 | 20% | 19% |
| 3 | 22% | 10% |
| 4 | 28% | 14% |
| 5 | 32% | 17% |
| 6 | 20% | 13% |
| 8 | 22% | 15% |
| 12 | 23% | 15% |
Whether 0 or 12 words went by, final recall went up and down but did not climb. Words replaced midway were recalled 10 to 19% of the time, words written at the end 19 to 32%, and the link with holding time was not statistically significant. In another experiment in the same paper, the number of times people rehearsed a word out loud was not related to later recall either. The authors concluded that rehearsal that only keeps an item in mind does not improve memory.
Repeating a phone number under your breath works for keeping it until you dial. It is not how you carry it to tomorrow.
So what does move information into long-term memory?
Thinking about meaning does. With the same words shown the same way, what people thought about them changed later memory several times over.
Craik and Tulving (1975) showed 20 college students words one at a time over 40 trials and asked one question just before each word. "Is the word in capital letters?" points at the letters. "Does the word rhyme with...?" points at the sound. "Is the word a type of...?" and "Would the word fit this sentence?" point at the meaning. The students thought it was a reaction-time study, and at the end they were asked, without warning, to pick out the words they had seen.
Words judged for meaning were recognized several times as often as words judged for case
- Answered yes
- Answered no
See the numbers
| Answered yes | Answered no | |
|---|---|---|
| Capital letters? | 18% | 14% |
| Rhymes with? | 78% | 36% |
| Type of? | 93% | 63% |
| Fits the sentence? | 96% | 83% |
For words answered yes, 18% of the case words and 96% of the sentence words were recognized. Answering the meaning questions took only about 0.15 to 0.2 seconds longer. The authors noted that, counted as study time, 200 extra milliseconds would have bought a 400% improvement, and argued it made more sense to credit the kind of processing, not the time. Experiment 2 (24 students, more distractors on the test) found the same shape for words answered yes, 15% after case questions and 81% after sentence questions (for words answered no, 19% and 49%).
Won't more time with the material do the same?
What you did mattered more than how long. A slow, shallow task did not beat a quick task about meaning.
Experiment 5 of the same paper measured this on its own. 24 students did one of two things with each word. One was to check its pattern of consonants and vowels: for brain, consonant, consonant, vowel, vowel, consonant. The other was to decide whether it fit the blank in a sentence. The consonant-vowel decisions took 1.7 seconds, the sentence decisions 0.85 seconds.
A shallow task that took twice as long left less than a quick one about meaning
- Answered yes
- Answered no
See the numbers
| Answered yes | Answered no | |
|---|---|---|
| Consonant-vowel pattern (1.7 s) | 57% | 50% |
| Fits the sentence (0.85 s) | 82% | 69% |
The slower consonant-vowel task left 57% and 50% recognized; the sentence task left 82% and 69%. The authors concluded that memory depends on the quality of processing, its depth, rather than the amount of time spent on it.
In one line What moves information into long-term memory is not how long it stays in mind but what you think while it is there. A moment on meaning outlasted twice as long on the letters.
Why does tying it to what you know help?
The authors' explanation is that a word tied into a meaningful context leaves a richer trace and more ways back to it later.
In Experiment 7, Craik and Tulving varied how rich the meaning was. Sentence frames ran from plain ("He dropped the ___") to elaborate ("The old man hobbled across the room and picked up the valuable ___ from the mahogany table"). The word (WATCH) was the same. When the word fit, richer sentences led to more recall later, and the difference grew when the sentence was shown again as a cue. For words that did not fit, sentence richness made no difference.
The authors summed it up this way: memory improves when the context and the word form an integrated unit, because a more elaborate trace is laid down and the structure of what you already know can be used to get back to it. The experiment varied sentence frames, not what students already knew, but the same idea suggests a use. When you write a new idea as "this works like X, and differs from Y here," X and Y can become cues for later.
How do you make it last once it is in?
Recall it, and recall it again after a gap. Encoding deeply is the start; retrieval and spacing keep it.
| What you do | What the studies found | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Think about meaning | Recognized several times as often as letter judgments | Craik & Tulving (1975) |
| Close the book and recall | More kept than rereading after 2 days and 1 week | Roediger & Karpicke (2006) |
| Space it out | The longer you need it, the longer the best gap | Cepeda et al. (2006) |
Roediger and Karpicke (2006) had students read two short prose passages, then recall one in writing and reread the other for the same 7 minutes. Separate groups took the final test 5 minutes, 2 days or 1 week later. At 5 minutes the reread passage did better (81% vs 75%). At 2 days (68% vs 54%) and 1 week (56% vs 42%), the recalled passage was kept better. In a second experiment, students who only reread a passage were more confident they would remember it a week later than students who had recalled it, yet remembered less.
Cepeda and colleagues (2006) analyzed 317 experiments from 184 articles. Spaced study beat massed study, and the gap that gave the best retention grew as the time until the test grew. For concrete review timings, see the spaced repetition schedule note.
How long does it take to become a long-term memory?
There is no fixed number of hours. What you do while studying sets it up, consolidation continues afterward, and sleep helps.
Rasch and Born (2013) reviewed more than a century of research and wrote that sleep benefiting memory retention is an established fact. Current theories see sleep not just as a time protected from interference but as an active stage of consolidation. In their account, recently learned memories are reactivated during slow-wave sleep and reshaped to fit into long-term memory. They describe the waking brain as optimized for taking memories in and the sleeping brain as optimized for consolidating them.
So rather than waiting on a number, encode deeply and sleep that night. Whether to cut sleep before an exam is covered in the note on sleep before an exam.
What to try today
- Attach a "why" to each thing you learn. If you are learning "mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell," answer "why call them a powerhouse?" You end up thinking about meaning instead of repeating the words.
- Tie it to something you know in one sentence. "This works like X from last week," "this differs from Y here." A margin is enough.
- When you finish, close the book and write three lines from memory. Do not copy. Write what comes back, then check.
- Recall it again the next day and a few days later. And do not cut sleep that night.
In Aloom
Aloom starts from your questions. You ask AI, keep only the answers worth keeping, and each one joins the answers you already kept in a knowledge graph. A new answer taking its place beside what you know is the "tie it to what you know" step of this note. Then each day you recall the number you chose, 1, 3 or 5, as questions before you see the answers. The more you recall a node, the darker its ink. See how Aloom works
FAQ
What is the difference between short-term and long-term memory?
Short-term memory is the small amount you are holding in mind right now. Long-term memory is what stays so you can bring it back later. The experiments in this note show that what links the two is not time spent in short-term memory but what you think about the information.
What is the difference between maintenance and elaborative rehearsal?
Maintenance rehearsal repeats an item to keep it in mind, like a phone number. Elaborative rehearsal works on its meaning and links it to other things you know. In Craik and Watkins (1973), maintenance rehearsal did not improve later recall.
Does repetition move information into long-term memory?
It depends on the kind. Repeating the same words in your head did not. Recalling with the book closed beat rereading on later tests, and spacing study out beat cramming it.
References
- Craik, F. I. M., & Watkins, M. J. (1973). The role of rehearsal in short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 12(6), 599–607.
- Craik, F. I. M., & Tulving, E. (1975). Depth of processing and the retention of words in episodic memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 104(3), 268–294.
- Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249–255.
- Cepeda, N. J., Pashler, H., Vul, E., Wixted, J. T., & Rohrer, D. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks: A review and quantitative synthesis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3), 354–380.
- Rasch, B., & Born, J. (2013). About sleep's role in memory. Physiological Reviews, 93(2), 681–766.