한국어

Is Building a Second Brain Worth It for Your Memory?

At a glance
  • A second brain is a note system outside your head where you save what you learn and pull it out when you need it.
  • While the notes are open, it works. In one study people found 89 to 94% of what they had written down.
  • But words people wrote down expecting to look them up later were recalled at only 30 to 36% without the notes.
  • People who knew the notes would be gone recalled 49 to 54% of the same kind of list.
  • Save what you only need to find. For what you want to know, set aside time to recall it with your notes closed.

A second brain is great for finding things again, but on its own it does not put them in your head. In experiments, people who wrote words down expecting to look at them later recalled only 30 to 36% of them without their notes, while people who knew the notes would be gone recalled 49 to 54%. Save what you only need to find, and set aside time to recall what you want to know with your notes closed. Then you get both.

What is a second brain?

It is a system of digital notes outside your head where you collect what you learn and think, and pull it out when you need it. The productivity writer Tiago Forte made the idea popular with a book and a course of the same name.

Forte describes building one in four steps: Capture, Organize, Distill and Express, or CODE. He is clear about the goal. Use your brain for having ideas and leave the storing to your notes. Offloading your thinking onto notes, he argues, frees your mind to imagine, create and simply be present (Forte 2023).

So a second brain was never designed as a memorization tool. It is a tool for not losing what you need for work, and for turning what you collected into writing or projects. For that goal it fits well. The question comes up when you also want what you saved to stay in your head.

Do you remember less of what you save?

Yes. What people wrote down expecting to see again later, they recalled less of without their notes. The same result came out in three experiments.

Kelly and Risko (2019) played lists of 20 words to college students and had them write each word on paper as they heard it. On the first three lists, students could look at their paper while they recalled the words. The researchers used this step to build trust in the paper. The fourth list was the real test. One group was told before the list, "this time you can't use your paper." The other group was told only after they had heard and written the words. Neither group got to use the paper. The only difference was whether they expected to have it while they were writing.

People who expected to see their notes again recalled less without them

  • Knew notes would be gone
  • Expected to see notes
0%20%40%60%80%100%Knew notes would be gone · 2019 Exp. 1a · 49%49%Expected to see notes · 2019 Exp. 1a · 36%36%2019Exp. 1aKnew notes would be gone · 2019 Exp. 1b · 51%51%Expected to see notes · 2019 Exp. 1b · 35%35%2019Exp. 1bKnew notes would be gone · 2022 replication · 54%54%Expected to see notes · 2022 replication · 30%30%2022replication51% vs 35%
Share of words recalled without notes on the last list. Both groups wrote down every word, and neither could see their notes at the test. The 2019 experiments played 20 words to 64 people each. The 2022 replication showed 19 words on screen to 192 people.Source: Kelly & Risko (2019) exploratory analyses, Kelly & Risko (2022) Results
See the numbers
Knew notes would be goneExpected to see notes
2019 Exp. 1a49%36%
2019 Exp. 1b51%35%
2022 replication54%30%

In the two 2019 experiments, the group that knew the notes would be gone recalled 49% and 51% of the words, and the group that expected the notes recalled 36% and 35%. When the same researchers ran it again in 2022 with 192 people, it was 54% against 30% (Kelly & Risko 2022). That study also asked people afterward about their strategy. Within the group that expected the notes, the more someone said they had planned to lean on the notes, the fewer words they recalled.

What exactly do you forget?

The loss fell mostly on the first words of the list, the ones people are thought to rehearse most. In the 2019 experiments, the last words were not hurt.

When people hear a list and then recall it, they usually remember the first few words well. The common explanation is that they rehearse those words while the list is still short. They also remember the last few, which are still fresh. Kelly and Risko (2019) looked at the two ends separately.

Far fewer of the first two words were recalled, but the last two were not hurt

  • Knew notes would be gone
  • Expected to see notes
0%20%40%60%80%100%Knew notes would be gone · First two words · 73%73%Expected to see notes · First two words · 34%34%First two wordsKnew notes would be gone · Last two words · 59%59%Expected to see notes · Last two words · 75%75%Last two words73% vs 34%
2019 Experiment 1b. Average share of the first two and the last two words of a 20-word list recalled without notes. Word order was randomized. On the last two words the group that expected notes was a little higher, but the difference was not statistically significant.Source: Kelly & Risko (2019), Experiment 1b
See the numbers
Knew notes would be goneExpected to see notes
First two words73%34%
Last two words59%75%

Of the first two words, the group that knew the notes would be gone recalled 73% on average, against 34% for the group that expected the notes. For the last two words it was 59% and 75%, slightly higher for those who expected the notes, though not a significant difference. The researchers saw this shape as similar to what you get when people are told to forget certain words. Their reading: when you believe the notes are there, you may write things down and stop there, without the effort of rehearsing them.

In the 2022 replication, the extra loss on the first two words compared with middle words came out smaller, and the researchers wrote that this part of the effect, if it exists, is likely small. In that study the last words were also recalled less by the group that expected notes. Still, in all three experiments the loss for the group that expected notes was bigger for the first words than for the last ones.

These were word lists, measured within one session. A real second brain is different: you choose what to save, and you come back days or months later. So the numbers don't transfer directly. The direction was the same each time, though. When people trusted that the notes would be there, they recalled less without them.

So is a second brain a bad idea?

No. While the notes were open, people found almost everything, and saving also made room for learning the next thing.

In Kelly and Risko (2022), on the first three lists, when people could use their notes, they recalled 89 to 94% of the words. Leaning on notes is a good strategy when you have them. In fact, on those lists the people who said they relied more on their notes scored higher. In Storm and Stone (2015), people who saved one file before studying a new one remembered more of the new file than when they did not save. The benefit disappeared when they believed the saving was unreliable. That study is covered in more detail in the Google effect note.

What you wantDo notes alone do it?
Find it again laterYes. With notes open, people found almost all
Free your mind for what's nextYes. After saving, people learned more
Recall it without notesNo. That takes practice recalling it

So a second brain is a good place to hand over the job of finding. The trouble starts when finding and knowing are treated as the same thing. Something being in your notes and being in your head are two different facts.

How do you get it into your head as well?

Add time to recall it with the notes closed. Rereading kept almost nothing extra.

Karpicke and Roediger (2008) had college students learn 40 Swahili-English word pairs. They compared students who kept recalling a word after they had gotten it right once with students who, after getting a word right, only restudied it or dropped it. All four groups did equally well while learning, and when asked how many they would remember in a week, all predicted about half.

In one line: a week later, students who kept recalling even the words they had already gotten right remembered about 80%. Students who stopped recalling those words remembered 36% and 33%. Every group had predicted about 50% (Karpicke & Roediger 2008).

Applied to a second brain: a weekly review where you reread your notes is closer to restudying. Trying to recall a note before you open it is retrieval. You don't need to do this for every note, only for what you want to know without your notes. Why you shouldn't drop the cards you already know is in the flashcards note.

What can you try today?

  1. Decide one thing when you save. Is this something to find, or something to know? Links, meeting notes and reference material are mostly things to find. Save them as they are.
  2. Give each thing to know a question. At the top of the note, write one line that hides the answer, like "What was the main point?" Later this is more useful than copied highlights.
  3. Recall from the question alone two days and a week later. Don't open the note yet. Say or write what comes to mind, briefly.
  4. Then open the note and check. Look again only at what you missed. Next time, recall the ones you got right once more.
  5. Change your weekly review. Instead of skimming your notes, recall only the few you marked as things to know this week, from their questions.

In Aloom

The point of this note is to save and recall together. Aloom keeps both in one place. You ask AI a question and keep only the answers worth keeping. Each kept answer is saved in your knowledge graph and linked to what you already know. Then, each day, you recall the 1, 3 or 5 answers you chose as a question first, before you see the answer. The more you recall a node, the darker its ink. Your kept answers are always there to look up, but in Aloom's review you try to recall before you look. You can keep your work material in the notes app you already use and put only the answers you want to remember in Aloom. See how Aloom works

Frequently asked questions

What does a second brain mean?

It is a way of managing personal knowledge where you collect what you learn and think in digital notes outside your head, and pull it out when you need it. Tiago Forte's CODE (Capture, Organize, Distill, Express) is the best-known version.

Do I need Obsidian for a second brain?

No. Obsidian, Notion, a notes app or a paper notebook can all work. What matters more than the tool is deciding which saved things you want to know, and recalling those without your notes. Linking notes is covered in the Zettelkasten note.

Can AI build my second brain for me?

For finding things, it is a good option. If AI collects, organizes and summarizes for you, finding gets easier. But if it also does the organizing you would have done yourself, even less may stay in your head. Studying from AI summaries is covered in the AI summaries note. What you want to remember, you still need to recall yourself after the AI has organized it.

References