한국어

How to Remember What You Read: Close the Book and Recall

At a glance
  • To remember what you read, closing the book and recalling it keeps more a week later than reading it again.
  • Students who read a text in four 5-minute sessions kept 40% a week later. Those who read it once and then recalled it three times kept 61%.
  • The rereaders felt more confident they would remember. Familiarity feels like memory, but it is not the same thing.
  • A major review rated highlighting and rereading as low-utility study techniques.
  • After each chapter, close the book and write three lines from memory, and turn your highlights into questions.

To remember what you read, close the book and recall it instead of reading it again. In one study, students who read a short text in four 5-minute sessions remembered 40% of it a week later, while students who read it once and recalled it three times remembered 61%. Highlights work the same way: looking at them again helps little, so turn them into questions and answer them from memory a few days apart.

Why do I forget what I read?

Some of what you remember right after reading fades within a week. That happens to everyone, and rereading does little to stop it: in the study below, students who only reread lost about half of what they could recall after 5 minutes (52%), while students who recalled three times lost 14%.

Roediger and Karpicke (2006) gave college students a short science passage, about the sun or about sea otters, and four periods: 5 minutes for each reading and 10 minutes for each recall. One group read it in all four periods. Another read it three times and then, in the last period, closed it and wrote down everything they could remember. A third group read it once and spent the other three periods writing from memory. Nobody was shown the correct answers after writing. Then, 5 minutes or 1 week later, everyone wrote down all they could recall.

After 5 minutes the readers led; after a week the recallers did

  • Read four times
  • Read three times, recall once
  • Read once, recall three times
0%25%50%75%100%Read four times · 5 minutes · 83%83%Read three times, recall once · 5 minutes · 78%78%Read once, recall three times · 5 minutes · 71%71%5 minutesRead four times · 1 week · 40%40%Read three times, recall once · 1 week · 56%56%Read once, recall three times · 1 week · 61%61%1 week40% vs 61%
Share of the passage's 30 idea units recalled on the final test. Every group had four periods, 5 minutes for each reading and 10 for each recall. 30 students per group.Source: Roediger & Karpicke (2006), Experiment 2 results
See the numbers
Read four timesRead three times, recall onceRead once, recall three times
5 minutes83%78%71%
1 week40%56%61%

On the 5-minute test, reading four times won with 83%. A week later the order flipped: the four-time readers had dropped to 40%, and the group that recalled three times still had 61%. The feeling that you know it all right after reading tells you little about what you will remember next week.

Doesn't reading it several times help?

Reading more did not mean remembering more. In the same study, the group that only read went through the text far more often, remembered less a week later, and was more confident it would remember.

The researchers had students count how many times they got through the passage in each period. Afterwards, students rated on a 1 to 7 scale how well they thought they would remember it in a week.

GroupTimes through the textConfidence (out of 7)Recall after 1 week
Read four times14.24.840%
Read three times, recall once10.34.256%
Read once, recall three times3.44.061%

The readers went through the text 14.2 times on average; the recallers, 3.4 times. More than four times the reading, and less left over. Rereading makes the text flow, and that ease feels like knowing. But what you need later is the ability to pull it out without the book, and that ability grows when you practice pulling it out.

In one line The sense of knowing you get from rereading is familiarity, not memory. Close the book and try to bring it back, and you find out what you actually remember.

Does highlighting help you remember?

Highlighting on its own does not make much stick. It is still useful as a marker for what you want to recall later.

Dunlosky and colleagues (2013) reviewed ten study techniques that students can use easily and asked whether their benefits held across ages, materials and kinds of tests. Highlighting (or underlining) and rereading were rated low utility. The authors note that most students report using both, yet neither consistently improves performance, and they recommend practice testing in place of rereading.

Tools that collect your highlights and show them to you again can be read the same way. Meeting an old highlight is a good reminder that a book exists, but reading the sentence again is close to rereading. That is why Readwise, alongside its Daily Review, has a separate feature called Mastery that turns a highlight into a question-and-answer card or a cloze deletion. Seeing a highlight and answering a question made from it are different activities.

Why does everyone reread anyway?

Because rereading feels like studying. Few students knew that recalling helps memory more.

Karpicke and colleagues (2009) asked 177 college students to list the strategies they use when studying. 84% listed rereading notes or the textbook, and 55% named it their top strategy. 11% described recalling from memory, and 6% listed highlighting. Then they asked: after reading a textbook chapter once, what would you rather do next?

Even when they could restudy afterwards, only 42% would close the book and recall

  • No restudy after recalling
  • Restudy allowed after recalling
0%25%50%75%100%No restudy after recalling · Restudy · 57%57%Restudy allowed after recalling · Restudy · 41%41%RestudyNo restudy after recalling · Recall from memory · 18%18%Restudy allowed after recalling · Recall from memory · 42%42%Recall frommemoryNo restudy after recalling · Something else · 21%21%Restudy allowed after recalling · Something else · 17%17%Something else18% to42%
Choices after reading a textbook chapter once. The first question went to 101 students, the second to a different 76. Four answers to the first could not be scored, so it does not add to 100%. We rounded to whole percent (original 57.4, 17.8, 20.7 and 40.8, 42.1, 17.1).Source: Karpicke, Butler & Roediger (2009), Tables 2 and 3
See the numbers
No restudy after recallingRestudy allowed after recalling
Restudy57%41%
Recall from memory18%42%
Something else21%17%

When recalling meant no chance to restudy, 17.8% chose it. Only 7.9% of all students said they would do it because recalling helps memory; 9.9% wanted to find out what they did not know. When students could restudy afterwards, the share rose to 42.1%. More than half still chose not to close the book.

How should I read so I remember?

After each chapter, close the book, recall what you can, and then open it only to fill the gaps. You can do this today with a pencil.

  1. Close the book after each chapter or section. Write three lines from memory, or say them out loud. Getting stuck is fine; where you get stuck is where to look next.
  2. Then open the book and fill only the gaps. Do not start over. Look up only what you could not bring back.
  3. Write a question next to each highlight. If you marked "habits start with identity," write "What did the author say to change first when changing a habit?" in the margin. Later, answer the question without looking at the sentence.
  4. Write your book notes the next day, with the book closed. Copying from an open book is close to rereading. For more on how much time to spend on notes, see Is Note-Taking a Waste of Time?
  5. A few days later and a week later, answer your questions once more. When to come back is covered in Spaced repetition schedule: when should you review?

The experiment above used short informational passages and college students. It did not test reading a novel for the story. For books you read to learn something, the same method is worth trying.

In Aloom

When a book makes you curious, you ask AI, keep only the answers worth keeping, and each one connects to what you already know in your knowledge graph. The core of this note, closing the book and recalling, is built into review: each day you recall 1, 3 or 5 answers, whichever you chose, from their questions before you see the answer again. Each recall darkens the node's ink, so you can tell what you have read from what you actually remember. Take a look at Aloom

FAQ

Why do I forget what I read right after reading it?

It is normal. In the study above, students who read the passage four times recalled 83% when tested after 5 minutes, but a separate group who studied the same way recalled 40% a week later. What made the difference was not ability but what they did after reading: those who recalled kept more.

Does highlighting help you remember?

Not much on its own. A large review rated highlighting, together with rereading, as low utility. What the research does support is recall, so turn the highlighted line into a question and answer it with the book closed.

Do I need to keep a reading journal to remember books?

Not necessarily. What matters is pulling the ideas out of your own head with the book closed. A notebook, explaining the book to a friend, or going over it in your mind on a walk all work, as long as recall is part of it.

References